‘UN Experts’ are an Oxymoron: US Secretary of State Marco Rubio Defends India’s Sovereignty
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio has dismissed recent criticism from United Nations experts regarding the Indian police’s handling of protests in Delhi as irrelevant, pointedly labeling the term “UN experts” as an “oxymoron.” During his current visit to India, Rubio firmly steered clear of commenting on the ongoing demonstrations against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, characterizing them as a strictly internal matter for the world’s largest democracy.
The protests, primarily led by youth groups in the capital, recently drew sharp remarks from a group of UN human rights experts in Geneva. These officials had expressed concern over what they described as a “heavy-handed” approach by Indian law enforcement, calling on the government to safeguard the right to peaceful assembly and address grievances related to alleged human rights violations.
A Matter of Domestic Policy
When pressed by reporters on the international backlash, Rubio was unequivocal in his refusal to intervene in India’s internal affairs. “It is a domestic political matter. I am not going to comment on it,” he stated. “This is a democracy, they have elections here. I am not going to opine on their domestic, political matters. We have protests every day in the US.”
Rubio’s remarks come during his second visit to India in just four months, signaling the strengthening strategic alignment between Washington and New Delhi. His stance underscores a broader shift in the current US administration’s approach, which favors respecting the sovereign processes of democratic allies over engaging with the narrative frameworks often pushed by international bureaucratic bodies.
India Rejects ‘Selective Targeting’
The Indian government has also launched a robust defense against the UN’s observations, accusing the organization of engaging in “selective targeting.” Representing India during a recent discussion at the Working Group on Enforced Disappearances, Barkha Tamrakar, Deputy Secretary in the Ministry of External Affairs, emphasized that India possesses comprehensive constitutional and institutional mechanisms to handle internal grievances.
Tamrakar argued that human rights discourse must not be manipulated into a tool for political leverage. “Human rights should not be used as an instrument of political pressure or selective country targeting,” she asserted. According to New Delhi, international engagement on such sensitive issues should be rooted in cooperation, transparency, and substantive dialogue, rather than the dissemination of unverified allegations.
The Ministry of External Affairs further clarified that while India is open to addressing documented cases through established legal channels, it remains staunchly opposed to efforts that attempt to malign the nation’s democratic credentials using incomplete data or flawed reports.
As Rubio prepares for his upcoming visit to Jamnagar, Gujarat, to continue discussions on bilateral ties, his dismissive posture toward the UN’s criticisms highlights the US’s commitment to maintaining a robust partnership with India, anchored in mutual respect for democratic sovereignty and an avoidance of interference in one another’s domestic political landscapes. The development reinforces the evolving nature of the India-US relationship, where strategic cooperation increasingly takes precedence over external moralizing.
Disclaimer: This content is auto-generated for informational purposes only.
Source: Read Original News
